What's the Difference Between a Restraining Order and a No-Contact Order?

A charge of domestic assault will most likely result in a temporary or permanent Abuse Prevention Order, also called a 209A Order. This order specifically prohibits contact between certain family members, ordering the alleged attacker to stay away from the alleged victim and their children. Famiy member can mean any of the following: people who are married to one another, people who live together, people who are related by blood or marraige, people who have a child together regardless of whether they have ever been married or lived together, or people who have been in a substantive dating or engagement relationship. In order to be granted a 209A Order, the plaintiff (the person who has been allegedly abused) needs to show a judge by a preponderence of the evidence that he or she is suffering from abuse. Abuse means any one of the following: attempting to cause or causing physical harm, placing another in fear of imminent serious physical harm, or causing another to engage involuntarily in sexual relations by force, threat, or duress. An intitial 209A Order is temporary, usually ten days.  If the plaintiff wants to extend the order, a hearing will be held with both the plaintiff and the defendant. At the extension hearing, a plaintiff needs to prove that the order is necessary to protect him or her from the likelihood of abuse and that he or she is in imminent fear of imminent serious physical harm. 

A 209A order may require you to refrain from:

• Appearing at the alleged victim’s home
• Showing up at the alleged victim’s workplace
• Making threats against the alleged victim
• Calling or texting the alleged victim
• Being within unacceptable close proximity to the alleged victim
• Threatening or attempting to harm the alleged victim
• Contacting the alleged victim through a third party
• Returning to your shared household
• Contacting the alleged victim through social media
• Contacting children in the alleged victim’s custody
• Making any other indirect or indirect contact with the alleged victim
• Appearing at the school, daycare, or workplaces of the alleged victim’s children
• Possessing any firearms or firearm identification cards to the police
• Having any contact with an animal owned or kept in the alleged victim’s household

The violation of a 209A Order is not just an additional offense, it will be seen as a failure to obey the court’s instructions. Furthermore, your actions when violating the order could lead to a new allegation of abuse, increasing the charges and potential punishments in your case.

A Massachusetts Harassment Prevention Order can be issued against anyone, not just a family member. Sometimes called a 258E Order, its goal is to prevent stalking, sexual harassment, or sexual assault of an alleged victim.

A person may be served with a 258E Order if they:

• Committed willful and malicious acts against someone. A harassment order may be served on anyone who has committed three or more intentional acts specifically aimed at the accuser with the intent to cause fear, intimidation, abuse, or damage to property, and were motivated by cruelty, hostility, or revenge.
• Forced someone to have sex. 258E Orders can be served on any person who forces, coerces, or threatens someone else into having sex at least once.
• Committed a sexually motivated offense against someone. The commission of any rape, statutory rape, indecent assault and battery, assault with intent to rape, criminal stalking, criminal harassment, drugging for sexual intercourse, or enticement of a child may result in a harassment order.

If you have been accused of violating a harassment order, you may still have some legal defenses, including:

• You were not served with the order. The Commonwealth has to prove that a valid protection order was issued by the court, and that you were properly notified that the order was in effect or knew of its terms.
• Your actions did not violate the terms of the order. This may be an available defense if the order was not in effect on the date of contact, or the alleged offense was not forbidden by the order.
• The violation was unintentional or accidental. You may have simply shown up in the same place at the same time as the person named in the protection order. In most cases, the court and prosecutors treat technical violations of the order differently than deliberate or intentional violations.

The best way to avoid violating a protection order is to avoid the accuser completely. Do not drive by their home or work, don’t call or message them, and block them on all social media platforms. If the alleged victim contacts you, do not respond. You could be charged of violating the order even if you did not initiate contact.

At Nate Amendola Defense, we help clients favorably resolve domestic violence and sexual assault cases and mitigate the collateral consequences that could negatively impact your life. Contact us today to set up a consultation and get answers to your questions.

If you’ve been arrested on an OUI/DUI charge, domestic violence, disorderly conduct, or drug possession, you should speak to an experienced defense attorney as soon as possible. You can contact us online or call our office directly at 781-740-0800 to schedule your free consultation with one of our top-notch defense lawyers. We have been proudly servicing clients throughout Norwell, Massachusetts, and surrounding areas such as Plymouth, Barnstable, Nantucket, and more.